Post-Publication Discussion

  1. Overview and Scope

JASEE (Journal of Application and Science on Electrical Engineering) encourages open, objective, and constructive scientific debate. The journal welcomes academic discussions, queries, and critiques regarding articles published in all areas of electrical engineering, including power systems, control and robotics, telecommunications, computer systems, and applied electronics.

  1. Forms of Discussion

Post-publication feedback may be submitted in the following forms:

- Letters to the Editor / Scientific Comments: Formal constructive feedback regarding methodology, data collection, mathematical modeling, experimental setup, or analytical interpretations of a published paper.

- Author Responses: Official rebuttals or clarifications provided by the original authors addressing published comments.

  1. Submission and Evaluation Process

- Submissions for post-publication discussion must be grounded in verified scientific evidence, logical reasoning, and objective data. Personal attacks or unsubstantiated allegations will be rejected.

- Submissions must be sent to the Editorial Office via the official communication email, clearly indicating the article title, volume/issue, DOI, and a clear summary of the scientific discussion.

- The Editorial Board will evaluate the submission for relevance and merit. If deemed suitable, the original author(s) will be granted the Right of Reply.

- Upon editorial review and peer verification, approved discussions and author responses may be published alongside or linked to the original article.

  1. Relation to Corrections, Errata, and Retractions

If a post-publication discussion uncovers significant technical errors, data calculation mistakes, or publication misconduct:

- Minor technical or formatting errors will be resolved through a formal Erratum or Corrigendum.

- Serious violations (such as data fabrication, plagiarism, or unresolvable fundamental flaws) will be handled in strict accordance with COPE guidelines, which may lead to an Expression of Concern or Article Retraction.